Get Creative with a DIY Super Mario Bros. Birthday Party

Last weekend we celebrated Zackary’s sixth birthday. He requested a Super Mario Bros. birthday party and I have to confess, I put off planning it a little longer than I should have; I had some potential reviews of birthday party supplies that ended up not working out so when he asked me exactly one week before his birthday, “Mom, am I even going to HAVE a party?” I knew it was time to get in gear!

With a limited budget and only a week to plan, I turned to Google to get some Super Mario party ideas. First, I printed off some free Mario-themed invitations from Personalized Party Invites. Rather than leave anybody out, I just invited every boy in Zackary’s class; thirteen in all.

Next on the agenda…games! I found two fun and free printable games online: Mario Bingo (download it here) and Pin the Moustache on the Mario. Then, to make sure that the baker’s dozen of little boys that would be coming burnt off some of their energy, I drew spots on a dozen eggs so that the boys could have a Yoshi Egg Race!

super mario hats water bottles and treat bags
The hats, bottles and treat bags for Zackary’s party. I love the way they looked all lined up in a row!

Rather than making traditional loot bags full of dollar-store items that would likely break within a few days, I decided to combine my Super Mario party ideas with a popular new trend and offer a few bigger items along with a dessert table.

I made each boy a Mario hat by cutting out the Mario logo from white felt and using felt glue to attach it to red ball caps I bought at the dollar store. At about $2.50 a hat, these were my biggest expense, but they looked so good when they were done!

mario water bottles
Here’s a closer look at the Mario water bottles. The names of the boys are printed on the side of the labels.

I also made each boy a personalized water bottle by printing Mario-themed labels on sticker paper and then attaching them to BPA-free plastic water bottles I bought for $1.25 each at the dollar store. To make the paper a little more water-resistant, I sprayed it with two coats of Clear Acrylic spray paint.

mario hats bottles bags
A large view of the hats and bottles. They were so quick and easy to make!

The treat bags were for the boys to fill with snacks from the dessert table. I had some cute paper bags left over from something else so I printed various Mario characters onto card stock, cut them out and stuck them onto the treat bags with glue dots for fun customized bags.

super mario bros dessert table
Zackary’s Super Mario Bros. dessert table! Once I saw it finished, it was totally worth the work!

The dessert table didn’t cost nearly as much as the hats and bottles since I had most of the ingredients for the treats in my cupboard, but it did take the most work! I started off by making Super Mario Bros. themed sugar cookie pops. Then, I created Mario marshmallow mushrooms by dipping large marshmallows in red candy coating and sticking slices of mini marshmallows to the coating when it was slightly cool. I rounded out the table with some chewy rainbow taffy, chocolate coins, round lollipops and “Yoshi” Kinder eggs!

super mario cookies and marshmallows
An up close look at the cookies and marshamallows. Yummy!

The crowning touch was the cake. This was my first experience working with fondant and for anyone that has considered trying it, I really can’t recommend it highly enough IF you make it yourself. Marshmallow fondant is surprisingly easy to make and, unlike store-bought fondant, which most people have told me tastes a lot like play dough, is completely delicious!

I used this Buttercream Marshmallow Fondant recipe from The Baking Beauties to make my fondant and a basic homemade carrot cake for the base.

super mario birthday cake
Zackary’s Super Mario Bros. birthday cake! Isn’t it fantastic?

The best part of a cake like this is that any unevenness in the fondant or imperfections that came with using fondant for the first time could be easily covered with one of the cute decorations! I had so much fun making little Mario figurines to decorate the cake. And I was so proud of how well my fondant Mario cake topper turned out!

super mario cake details
Some of the details on Zackary’s Super Mario Bros. cake. I love the little mushrooms!

The party was lots of fun but also completely exhausting. I kept prizes simple by making some cute “You Win!” stickers featuring Mario and Luigi with another sheet of sticker paper and then giving them out to the boys that won the games. And of course, no Super Mario birthday party would be complete without a Mario Kart tournament in the basement playroom!

zackary and friends with his mario cake
Zackary getting ready to blow out the candles on his cake…dressed as Mario, of course!

By the time the boys happily left with full treat bags and Mario hats on their heads (and I had flopped onto the couch in exhaustion) the party had cost about $100. It was more than I originally intended to spend, but considering that I would have likely paid the same amount just for the cake if I had bought it at a bakery, I was pretty pleased!

The hats had been the biggest expense, but seeing the boys’ delight when they received them made them worth it. And I can’t help but grin when I drop Zackary off at school and see one of his classmates wearing a Mario hat!

It was a busy week and it took some work and a lot of researching Super Mario party ideas, but giving my son the Super Mario birthday party he wanted was actually pretty easy and affordable! If you have a child’s birthday party coming up and you’re short on money or time, just get creative. If I can do it, you can do it too!

14 thoughts on “Get Creative with a DIY Super Mario Bros. Birthday Party”

    1. Aww, thanks Brandi! I put it together in a week because I had some birthday party gear reviews that fell through, so I was pretty proud of myself. My gosh, I was dead on my feet by the end of the week though!

  1. I would never have imagined somewhere thinking up and making all of these creations by themselves, you’ve got a lot of talent!

    1. Thanks so much Holly! The cookies and marshmallow pops were based on ideas I found online, so I don’t get the credit for thinking them up, just for recreating them! :) Google’s always a wonderful source of great easy party ideas and a printer with a full ink supply to use for crafts can do wonders!

    1. Thanks so much, Mellisa! :) It’s the most work I’ve ever put into a party, so I’m REALLY glad it all turned out. I was so worried I even had a back-up cake planned just in case this one was a disaster! LOL

  2. I wholeheartedly endorse this birthday party! Looks amazing all around. I love the homemade touches on everything from the water bottles to the mushroom pops! Amazing job!

    1. Thanks Andrew, you totally made my day! :) I’m a big fan of handmade, and not just because it’s easier on the wallet. It’s also way more satisfying when the kids see all the goodies and their faces light up!

    1. Oh gosh, gingermommy, you have got to give that Buttercream Marshmallow Fondant a try! It really is a dream to work with and makes things look so professional! (And the fact it doesn’t taste like playdough is a big plus too! LOL)

  3. Kat's Confessions

    WOW! That is one awesome birthday party! You did an amazing job on everything! Happy belated birthday to your little one!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *